COMISSÃO DE DEFESA DO CONSUMIDOR

Hello. Thank you. Thank you. President, first... You would like to respond As ponderations of the deputies. - Yeah. I have two points of discordance. The first is that this Commission doesn't or so expressed. On the contrary, this is a long time of seven years I have been here in all us and all the meetings. different from the deputado. Thank you. We produce much. And everything that is approved here is detailed analysis. verified and ponderado, alterado and after this discussion is approved. And this is interesting because, contrary to other commissions, that are approved by lot, without the most concern, and then causes a negative effect. Volume is not productivity. But, to work very well, doesn't mean that there is a result. If it was like, a buraco would give a result. The second point is that I... I would like to be a market, and not to respect the scope of the Commission, which would be a of the consumer. And I'm going to be a little bit of this argument, because I just said, before I just said that Encarecer product or service creates a social exclusion. It's a rule. You can't agree with the argument. but to say that I'm not worried about the consumer is a argumentative falacy. I said that to ensure the product and service, which is a rule of market, affects the consumer, You create a social exclusion. or a "abrangency" or a "a product or service or service" or "not care of service" and the product. It's not. It's not. It's not. If the product or service is less limited to consume it, And if I try to protect the consumer so that the product or service doesn't go up, I'm protecting the consumer. The consumer, in a broad sense, is not only the one who is in the system for financial reasons. And who defend the consumer that is in the system and who have the conditions of pay it, this, yes, is defending the big businesses, the big companies. And I want to open the open to all. I want to talk about the leader, President. the minority. Thank you. Concedida. - Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Mm-hmm. Thank you. Thank you. - Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So, in fact, I would like to restable the to the table? how it is healthy to debate. I can't agree with V. Ex. But I will not presume that you don't have at least the intention, even though I think it's ingenious, of protecting the consumer. which was what you told me. Well, I'm telling you that my intention is to protect the consumer. Why? Because having less regulation, have less bureaucracy, "Terminous impostos, faz com que ele be a consumer a bill have the possibility of contratting, of buying. Today, the state does the contrary. He created a manicomial Legislative that no one can't understand here. And I ask something and I don't know, and people here don't know, but it's supposed to be that the common citizen knows the resolution of the ministry, the generic legislation, the specific legislation. It's funny because in these days, He thinks that the common citizen will know all this legislation. But at the moment he thinks that this man is a idiot. Because they want to prove, for example, that in the phone, which is on the pauta of today, there is a 30% of information that using a lot of phone calls. being different from the cigar, the guy takes the phone and throws it out, and he stays 2, 3, 4 years with the phone. But not. The consumer is an idiot. assume that he doesn't know that the excessive use of the cellar does mal. I ask, does anyone here in the room don't know that the excessive use of the cellar does mal? Thank you. But then you will be obligated to to buy the phone with this information with 30% of their information with this. I'm wondering why it's not 25%, it's 35%, but it's because the political here in Brazil will offer a law for Apple I'm imagining the CEO receiving this office saying that now here for Brazil it should be like this. There is another project that has to choose the source. What is the source of information? There is another law that says that when the product is consumed by adults, Then it has to be another source, a source of information. There is another project on the pauta that says that It can be, for example, now, from now, it will be forbidden to sell chá sabor leite mel. It was now approved. It was prohibited. There are 11 projects in the Senate, that prohibit Also, the expression "leite" when there is no one. 11. Coitado do chá sabor leite mel, because it's going to be forbidden the commercialization by two laws. "The use of the word "leite" and "the use of the word "mel"" Remember that this law, in the majority of the majority, was approved in the Senate's office. to see the concerns of the deputies. It's not the real world. It's not a "file do pão". It's not the market of the market, not the remedy of 37% of the tax. Today, the CINJ was approved by 240 charges. He wants to help the consumer? He doesn't approve this. He doesn't approve this expense for him to pay. This helps the consumer. Give more money to him to contract a health plan. Thank you. to not be a refem do SUS, for example. There are people 6, 7, 8 months waiting for an exam. It's simple. This commission has the scope, the objective of helping the consumer, or who wants to be a consumer. And nothing more helps the consumer when gives freedom to him. He doesn't treat him as an idiot. and especially leave the money in his pocket without having that respect and understand the enormous and impossible of rules and laws that this Congress is going to be shot and disparate the time all. Thank you. I guarantee that no one here in the Commission will have capacity, President, nor V. Ex. and I, to say which laws were approved this month. on the Senate. They don't have capacity. And look, we are at the beginning of the month. right at the beginning of the month. There are 2.400 projects in the field of experience. "The man is waiting for the urgency." He wants to make a a We have a great deal of revogations. And then we leave people free, Thank you. and wrong. without interference that costs expensive and doesn't serve for anything, buy and sell what they want. And this is defending the consumer. It's what I do day to day in this commission. And I'm not pushing him to, to have to buy or sell anything that is. It's all. Produzir não é volume, é qualidade, ainda mais quando se trata de legislação. O Brasil não vai mal porque falta regra, lei ou imposto. O Brasil vai mal porque tem muita lei, regra e imposto. And unfortunately there is a metric equivocal, because every candidate when he goes to election, he says: "I'm going to bureaucratize, I'm going to regulament." Well, he comes here and does exactly the opposite every day. Sometimes, which is not the case of the dep. Gisela, A prova sem ler. "I'm not sure." without breaking up. And then a consequence, sometimes not intentional, it affects 200 million people. Thank you. Because today, the phone is a, for example, a important thing for the citizen. The life of the life is a important thing for the citizen. This project here has a important intention for the citizen. So these would be my considerations. Thank you. Thank you. Oui.